Advantage Play vs Casino Crime.png

Casino Cheating or Simply Beating

Casinos exist because the mathematics normally favour the house. Blackjack has a house edge. Roulette has a house edge. Baccarat has a house edge. Slot games are designed around a theoretical return to player that remains below 100% over the long term. The customer is perfectly entitled to win on any particular night, but the commercial model assumes that, across millions of bets, the casino ultimately retains an advantage.

That creates one of gambling’s most fascinating questions.

What happens when the player becomes better at the game than the casino expected?

If someone studies blackjack strategy until they make virtually perfect decisions, is that cheating? What if they mentally track the cards that have already appeared? What if they notice a defect on the backs of cards that the casino itself failed to notice? What if a dealer accidentally exposes information? What if casino software contains a mistake that makes a game substantially more favourable than intended?

At what point does intelligent gambling become advantage play, at what point does advantage play breach casino rules, and when does it finally cross the much more serious line into cheating or criminal conduct?

The answer is not simply whatever the casino says it is.

Nor is the answer automatically whatever the player calls “advantage play.”

The line is determined by a mixture of the rules of the game, contractual terms, gambling regulation, consumer law, the player’s conduct and, when the dispute becomes serious enough, the courts.

The Casino Is Supposed to Have an Advantage — But There Is No Rule Saying the Player Has to Be Bad

The starting point is important.

A gambler is not required to play badly.

A blackjack player is entitled to understand basic strategy. A poker player is entitled to read opponents. A sports bettor can build sophisticated statistical models. A bettor can notice that one bookmaker has priced a market differently from everybody else. A roulette player can choose bets intelligently even though doing so does not eliminate the mathematical house advantage.

Simply possessing more knowledge than the average customer cannot sensibly be described as cheating.

Competition frequently involves discovering information, patterns or weaknesses that the opposing side failed to recognise.

Casinos themselves do exactly this.

They analyse customers, calculate probability, adjust games, impose limits, change promotional terms and monitor profitable players. Sportsbooks employ traders and risk-management systems specifically designed to identify bettors who consistently obtain favourable prices.

The difficult question therefore becomes:

If the casino is entitled to use every legitimate piece of information available to protect its advantage, why should the player not be entitled to do the same?

That is where advantage play begins.

What Is Advantage Play?

Advantage play broadly describes legitimate techniques intended to reduce or reverse the mathematical advantage ordinarily enjoyed by the house.

There is no single legal definition covering every situation.

Some forms involve nothing more than mathematics. Others involve observing information accidentally revealed by the casino. At the extreme end are techniques in which the player persuades casino employees to change the physical conditions of a game without explaining the real reason.

It is at that point that the distinction between observation and manipulation becomes critical.

The UK Supreme Court’s landmark Ivey v Genting Casinos decision demonstrates exactly why.

Read the UK Supreme Court case: Ivey v Genting Casinos

Phil Ivey and the £7.7 Million Question

Professional gambler Phil Ivey played Punto Banco baccarat at Crockfords in London in 2012.

He and fellow professional gambler Cheung Yin Sun were able to identify minute manufacturing differences on the backs of certain playing cards.

The technique became known as edge sorting.

Merely seeing those differences was not enough. The cards needed to be orientated in particular directions so that valuable cards could subsequently be distinguished from other cards while still face down.

Ivey did not personally touch the cards.

Instead, requests were made to the dealer to rotate particular cards, ostensibly because of superstition. The casino accommodated those requests without understanding their significance.

Once the differently orientated cards remained in that configuration through subsequent play, Ivey possessed information that dramatically changed the odds.

He eventually won approximately £7.7 million.

Crockfords refused to pay.

Ivey argued that he had not cheated. He considered himself an advantage player who had simply identified a casino weakness and exploited it more effectively than the casino had protected itself.

The dispute eventually reached the Supreme Court.

The court rejected Ivey’s claim.

But the reasoning is more important than simply saying that “edge sorting is cheating.”

The Supreme Court acknowledged that there can be legitimate conduct that gives a player an advantage. Indeed, the judgment suggested that merely noticing distinguishable card backs and using that information might present a very different question.

What made Ivey’s conduct different was that he had taken positive steps to change the state of the game.

Through the unwitting dealer, the cards had effectively been arranged in a way that enabled him to know information the game was designed to keep random.

The Supreme Court concluded that this amounted to cheating.

That distinction is fundamental.

Observation is one thing. Manipulation is another.

The Law Does Not Give Us a Simple List of Everything That Counts as Cheating

Section 42 of the Gambling Act 2005 creates the offence of cheating at gambling in Great Britain.

The legislation also covers doing something to enable or assist somebody else to cheat.

Crucially, the Act says cheating can include actual or attempted deception or interference connected with the way gambling is conducted or with a real or virtual game.

A person does not even have to succeed in winning for the provision potentially to apply.

Read Section 42 of the Gambling Act 2005

What Parliament did not do was create an exhaustive catalogue saying:

card counting = legal
edge sorting = illegal
dealer errors = legal
computer glitches = illegal.

That would be virtually impossible because gambling constantly evolves.

Instead, courts have to examine what actually happened.

The Supreme Court recognised this difficulty in Ivey. What amounts to cheating in one game might be completely legitimate competition in another. Poker provides an obvious example: misleading an opponent about the strength of your hand is part of the game. Secretly replacing a card is not.

The context determines the boundary.

The Best Test May Be: Did You Observe the Game or Change the Game?

There is no universal statutory test expressed in precisely these words, but it is a useful way of understanding the dividing line.

Imagine several progressively more aggressive scenarios.

A blackjack player memorises perfect basic strategy.

Nothing has been interfered with.

The player simply makes better decisions.

Move further.

The player mentally remembers which cards have appeared and uses that information when deciding how much to wager.

Again, the cards have not been altered and the dealer has not been deceived into changing them.

Move further again.

The player notices that one particular group of cards has a slightly different pattern on its reverse side.

The casino supplied those cards.

The player notices the difference without touching them or asking anybody to reposition them.

Now the situation becomes more interesting, but it is still primarily one of observation.

Move further still.

The player deliberately persuades the dealer to rotate specific cards while concealing the real purpose so those cards can later be recognised.

That was essentially the territory reached in Ivey.

The player has progressed from reading the game better than the casino to actively altering the conditions under which the game operates.

That is where courts become substantially more receptive to the argument that the conduct is cheating.

What About Card Counting?

Card counting occupies perhaps the most famous grey area in casino gambling.

Traditional blackjack card counting does not require marked cards, electronic devices or collaboration with a dealer.

The player watches cards that the casino openly reveals during normal play and mentally estimates whether the cards remaining in the shoe are relatively favourable to the player or the dealer.

In Britain, the Gambling Commission has recently confirmed something particularly interesting: it does not maintain a general policy declaring card counting lawful or unlawful, and says any view it takes would depend upon the specific facts of an individual case.

UK Gambling Commission: Section 42, card counting and cheating

That is a more accurate position than the simplistic statement sometimes encountered online that “card counting is illegal” or, conversely, that every imaginable form of card counting is unquestionably protected.

Pure mental observation is very different from manipulating cards, colluding with employees or using prohibited equipment.

But even when conduct is not criminal cheating, the casino may have another option.

It can stop taking your action.

Legal Does Not Necessarily Mean the Casino Has to Keep Playing Against You

This is one of the most misunderstood aspects of advantage gambling.

There are really two separate questions:

Have you cheated?

and:

Must the casino continue accepting your bets?

They are not the same question.

The Gambling Commission explains that gambling is a commercial arrangement between willing parties. There is no general statutory right requiring a gambling operator to accept every bet from every customer. Operators can decline wagers or manage the commercial risk they are prepared to accept.

Gambling Commission: the legal status of a bet as a contract

That creates an unusual situation.

A player could potentially be doing nothing criminal and still be told:

We don’t want your business anymore.

Bookmakers restrict profitable bettors.

Casinos can change game conditions.

Online operators may reduce limits or end a commercial relationship, subject to applicable regulatory and consumer-law obligations.

Being barred or restricted therefore does not prove that somebody cheated.

Sometimes it proves only that the operator no longer likes the economics of playing against that customer.

America Has Produced an Even Clearer Card-Counting Case

The famous American case of Uston v Resorts International Hotel provides another useful illustration.

Kenneth Uston was a professional blackjack player and card counter. Resorts International excluded him because his strategy could shift the blackjack advantage in his favour.

The New Jersey Supreme Court examined whether the casino itself had the authority to exclude him specifically for counting cards.

The court concluded that, under the particular New Jersey regulatory framework existing at the time, the Casino Control Commission had exclusive authority over the permitted rules and methods of blackjack. Because the Commission had not prohibited Uston’s strategy, Resorts could not simply create its own prohibition and exclude him on that basis.

The ruling was highly jurisdiction-specific and should not be interpreted as creating a universal right to card count in every casino.

But one observation from the case remains extremely important: Uston had not changed the cards or manipulated the equipment.

He had played the blackjack game offered by the casino more effectively than the casino wanted him to.

Read Uston v Resorts International Hotel

That is competition in its purest and most uncomfortable form for the house.

Casino Rules Are Not the Same Thing as Criminal Law

Another source of confusion is the phrase “against the rules.”

There are several different sets of rules operating simultaneously.

There are the mathematical rules of the game.

There are house rules.

There are website terms and conditions.

There are promotional rules.

There are licence conditions imposed on the operator.

There is consumer law.

And finally there is criminal law.

Violating one does not automatically mean violating all of them.

A casino could, for example, prohibit the use of a telephone at the blackjack table.

Ignoring that instruction could result in someone being removed from the premises.

That does not automatically mean the customer has committed the criminal offence of cheating.

Similarly, an online casino may specify particular conditions governing a bonus. Breaching a valid and properly communicated bonus condition might affect entitlement to bonus funds.

Again, that is not automatically criminal fraud.

The seriousness depends upon what was actually done.

Casinos Cannot Simply Write “Anything We Don’t Like Is Cheating”

This point is especially important for online gambling.

Operators have historically used broad expressions such as “bonus abuse,” “irregular play,” “low-risk betting” or “advantage play.”

But consumer law limits how much discretion can be hidden inside vague contractual terminology.

The Competition and Markets Authority examined this issue directly.

It criticised terms that allowed operators to decide after the event that a customer’s perfectly ordinary betting strategy constituted unacceptable “abuse.”

The CMA said operators should clearly explain prohibited patterns of promotional play and distinguish them from much more serious conduct such as fraud, collusion, multiple accounts, software manipulation or deliberate cheating.

CMA: Online gambling, fairness and gameplay restrictions

This is extremely significant.

A casino cannot reasonably advertise a game, accept the player’s bets, allow the player to win and then retrospectively invent an unwritten rule that says:

“You played too intelligently, therefore your winnings are void.”

The relevant restrictions have to be legally effective, fair and sufficiently transparent.

The Gambling Commission’s current licence conditions reinforce this principle. Gambling terms must comply with the Consumer Rights Act 2015 and must be fair and transparent.

UK Gambling Commission: Fair and transparent gambling terms

And Operators Cannot Give Themselves Unlimited Discretion

The Gambling Commission goes even further in its guidance.

Terms giving the operator complete discretion over whether winnings are withheld because it believes there has been “illegal, irregular or fraudulent play,” multiple accounts or third-party activity can themselves create fairness problems.

Players are entitled to understand the consequences attached to defined conduct rather than discovering after winning that the casino has reserved unlimited discretion to decide what the rules mean.

Gambling Commission guidance on operators’ discretionary terms

That does not protect fraudsters.

It protects the distinction between fraud and a customer who simply played successfully.

What If You Discover a Software Error?

This is perhaps the online equivalent of spotting an unusual card.

Suppose a casino releases a blackjack game containing an unknown programming defect.

A customer presses the normal buttons, places normal bets and begins winning far more frequently than expected.

Has the customer cheated?

Not necessarily.

The extraordinary case of Green v Betfred demonstrates why.

Andrew Green played an online blackjack game called Frankie Dettori’s Magic Seven Blackjack in January 2018.

After approximately five and a half hours, his displayed winnings exceeded £1.7 million.

Betfred initially appeared to treat him as a legitimate winner but subsequently said an undiscovered software problem had caused the game to behave incorrectly.

The crucial fact was that the defect was unknown both to Betfred and to Green.

Green had not hacked anything.

He had not altered the program.

He had simply continued playing the game presented to him.

Betfred relied on contractual provisions dealing with malfunctions and software errors, but the High Court concluded that the relevant exclusions did not successfully protect the operator in these circumstances.

Green won the case.

Read Green v Betfred — the £1.7m blackjack software case

Again the underlying principle is revealing.

A casino’s mistake is not automatically the player’s fraud.

But What If the Player Knows About the Bug?

This is where the line becomes much less comfortable.

Imagine someone accidentally discovers that performing an unusual sequence of actions produces a payout the game was never intended to make.

Merely encountering the error is one thing.

Deliberately manipulating software, bypassing controls, interfering with systems or deceiving an operator so the defect can repeatedly be exploited can involve entirely different legal considerations.

The distinction resembles the physical casino.

Observing something the casino openly reveals can potentially be legitimate.

Actively manipulating the mechanism producing the result is far more likely to create a cheating or fraud issue.

Even then, individual facts matter.

There is no sensible legal rule stating that every person who notices a programming mistake becomes a criminal the moment they continue playing.

Knowledge, conduct, interference, deception, contractual obligations and the precise mechanism involved all become relevant.

What About Dealer Mistakes?

Dealer errors create another fascinating boundary.

Suppose a blackjack dealer accidentally exposes the hole card.

The player sees it.

Should the player deliberately forget what they have just seen?

That proposition seems difficult.

The casino itself accidentally supplied information during the ordinary conduct of the game.

But imagine instead that a player deliberately positions themselves, uses another person or manipulates the dealer in order to force hidden information to be exposed.

The facts have changed.

The difference again concerns passive observation versus deliberate interference.

Casino security departments naturally dislike both because each can cost the casino money.

Law, however, does not necessarily regard both situations as equivalent.

Casino Skill Is Encouraged Until It Starts Working Too Well

This creates one of gambling’s great contradictions.

Casinos often advertise games using language associated with skill, strategy and expertise.

Blackjack guides teach players when to hit, stand, split and double.

Poker celebrates professional players.

Sports betting businesses publish statistics, form guides and analytical content.

Customers are encouraged to believe that knowledge matters.

Yet when a tiny minority become sufficiently sophisticated to overturn the house advantage, the relationship can change very quickly.

The skilled player becomes a “sharp.”

The blackjack strategist becomes an “advantage player.”

The profitable customer becomes a risk-management problem.

There is nothing inherently improper about a casino managing that commercial risk.

But that is different from labelling successful play criminal cheating.

Those concepts should never be confused.

The Real Boundary Is Often Whether the Player Changed the Information or Merely Used It

A useful conceptual distinction emerges from the major cases.

If information exists naturally within the game and the player is simply better at interpreting it, that looks much more like competition.

If the player deliberately causes supposedly secret information to become available, manipulates game equipment, alters cards, deceives staff into changing the state of play or interferes with software, the conduct begins moving toward cheating.

There will always be difficult cases between those extremes.

That is precisely why the Supreme Court resisted creating a rigid universal definition in Ivey.

Casino games differ too much.

What constitutes legitimate deception in poker could be cheating in blackjack.

Information that is intentionally public in one game coul